People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Elisa was so lovely to us even though we ordered in many many shifts and had late members of our party! Food and drinks lovely as always, thank you! ”
“ My wife and I visited Turtle Bay for food and drinks. Lena our hostess while we were at Turtle Bay was amazing. She was very friendly, attentive and informative about the items on the menu. Lena also recommended a cocktail which I tried. It was very nice. Lena looked after us very well during our visit. We absolutely love this place and can't wait to come back. ”
“ Hanna our server was so attentive & made the bottomless brunch worth the value for money! The food was cooked to perfection. Only 4 stars for atmosphere as would have liked more music or a dj on a Saturday! ”
“ Food and drink all amazing, excellent staff, couldn't ask for better service. Daniel the server was polite and efficient. Had a drink at the bar too Sam served us was constantly on the go, but still found time to talk to us. Fantastic customer service from all. Good value for money. Definitely worth a visit weather for food or drinks. ”
“ We visited turtle bay for my friend’s birthday. We had a great time. fantastic food and delicious cocktails. Adam was our server he was friendly, funny and very attentive. We are definitely going to come back. ”
“ Madison was very friendly and attentive! 3 we asked her for recommendations which she was more than happy to give and she had a very good vibe similar to the atmosphere. We will definitely be back and enjoyed our time here!! Thank you ”
“ Lena was so lovely, super friendly and constantly made sure we had everything we needed, pleasure to talk to!!! food was lovely and drinks too x ”
“ Had an amazing time at Turtle Bay, and honestly, the highlight of the night was Ted the waiter. From the moment we arrived, he made us feel so welcome – super friendly, funny, and genuinely seemed to enjoy looking after us. Ted gave the best recommendations (those cocktails? Spot on), kept the vibes high all evening, and somehow managed to make everyone at the table feel special. You can tell he really knows his stuff – whether it was helping us choose from the menu or just having a laugh between courses. The food was full of flavour as always, and the atmosphere was lively, but it was Ted who really made it memorable. Big shoutout to him – if you’re heading to Turtle Bay, ask for Ted. Legend. ”
Menu
Jerk Chicken
173 Black Cherry
Caribbean Candy Sour
Classic Mojito
Coconut Espresso Martini
About
Turtle Bay Sheffield
Welcome to Turtle Bay Sheffield, where the vibrant spirit of the Caribbean comes alive in the heart of Sheffield City Centre. Located at Unit 2, NUM Building, 18 Holly St, Sheffield S1 2GT, this lively venue invites you to indulge in a feast of bold flavors and tropical inspirations that will transport you straight to the sun-soaked shores of the Caribbean.
At Turtle Bay Sheffield, the culinary journey begins with signature dishes that resonate with authenticity. The Jerk Chicken, marinated for an impressive 24 hours in a unique blend of aromatic spices, is a must-try. Grilled to perfection, the smoky char you’ll savor is bound to leave you hooked. Accompanied by a rich jerk gravy infused with hints of thyme and allspice, this dish epitomizes the addictive flavors that the Caribbean is celebrated for. Another fan favorite is the Brown Chicken, a hearty stew that features tender chicken thighs enveloped in a rich blend of onions, garlic, tomatoes, and spices. It’s comfort food that warms your soul.
As if the food isn't enticing enough, Turtle Bay Sheffield offers a variety of refreshing cocktails that beautifully complement the culinary offerings. The Montego Bae mixes Wray & Nephew rum with fresh fruit flavors, while the Guava Breeze indulges your palate with dark rum, tropical guava, and mango. For those who enjoy a tangy kick, the Mango Paloma provides a delightful twist with every sip. Whether you're unwinding after a long day or celebrating with friends, these cocktails set the perfect mood.
But it's not just the food and drink that make Turtle Bay Sheffield a standout destination. Customer experiences echo the warmth and hospitality you can expect. Niamh shared her joy about the attentive service from Elisa, who made accommodations for her party with ease. Similarly, David highlighted Lena's exceptional friendliness and knowledge of the menu, enhancing their dining experience. These personal touches echo throughout the restaurant, creating an inviting atmosphere filled with laughter and camaraderie.
For those looking to enjoy a lively brunch, reviews mention the invigorating bottomless brunch experience, with attentive servers ensuring customer satisfaction. While some guests desired a touch more music on Saturdays, the overall atmosphere remains vibrant and filled with opportunities to mingle.
In conclusion, Turtle Bay Sheffield is not just a dining destination; it's an experience filled with rich flavors, friendly service, and a lively atmosphere. If you're seeking a delightful escape to the tropics right here in Sheffield, be sure to visit this vibrant eatery. You’ll leave with a full belly, a happy heart, and likely, plans to return for more!
Book a table